THE PROBLEM
There is a human rights crisis in prisons in the United States today.
Every day, millions of people are dehumanized, terrorized, tortured, and denied proper medical care by prison administrators and guards in blatant disregard for law, policy, civil rights, and basic human decency.
The scale of human devastation across our criminal legal system is almost beyond comprehension. At this moment, there are 1.3 million people incarcerated in United States prisons, and an average of 450,000 people are admitted and released every year. The result is that 1 in 20 Americans are incarcerated at some point in their lifetime, and nearly 1 in 2 Americans (45%) have an immediate family member who has spent at least one night in jail or prison.
The impact of incarceration is profoundly consequential, regardless of the crime committed or the sentence served. A vicious combination of disconnection from family, loss of autonomy, lack of purpose, unpredictability, overcrowding, stays in solitary confinement, and trauma from witnessing violence or abuse creates long-lasting effects on mental and spiritual well-being.
Mass incarceration has had such a profound effect on public health that it has led to an identifiable and statistically significant decline in the life expectancy of the country as a whole.
Incarceration destroys people physically, mentally, and spiritually, and that damage perpetuates cycles of poverty, illness, and violence that reverberate through our families and communities. And yet, there is little moral outrage or legal consequence for this human devastation.
Three Key Reasons for This Crisis
Invisibility
Prisons are black boxes, often hidden in remote, rural areas. The people with vested interests in maintaining and growing carceral institutions have complete control of the narrative about them. The information flowing in and out of prisons is almost entirely controlled by prison staff. All correspondence is monitored, and it is very difficult (if not impossible) to tour a prison. Very few records of prison condition violations exist. The result is that the reality of the suffering behind prison walls is greatly obscured.
Impunity
The policies and laws that do exist to protect prisoners' rights are loosely and erratically enforced. Prison administrators and staff have almost total impunity over the maintenance of their facilities, and state and federal departments of corrections, whose interests mostly align with prison staff, internally manage most oversight and accountability mechanisms. Especially since the passage of the Prison Litigation Reform Act in 1996, the pathways for meaningful legal accountability for prisoners' rights violations have almost entirely closed.
Dehumanization
There is a widespread belief that justice, accountability, and safety is achieved through torturous conditions. The American public has normalized the dehumanization of criminalized people and chosen to believe that prisons help more than they harm, despite strong evidence to the contrary. When criminalization intersects with other marginalized identities, as it so often does, like being poor, Black, foreign-born, disabled, addicted, or queer, this mindset deepens fissures in our social and political fabric that have profound consequences for us all.
It does not have to be this way.
Our communities will never be truly healthy or safe if that "safety" is predicated on the dehumanization of millions of people. It is up to us to protect our people and to demand a system of justice that is decent, fair, and healthy for us all.